Content Provider: Angel Laidlaw
When communities seek to drive economic growth, job creation often becomes the go-to metric for measuring success. On the surface, it seems like an obvious choice—more jobs mean more opportunities for residents and a boost to the local economy. However, while job creation is an important aspect of economic development, focusing solely on this metric can be misleading and, at times, even harmful. Truly successful communities go beyond job numbers, embracing a more comprehensive view of what it takes to foster long-term economic growth and prosperity.
Why Job Creation Is Not Enough
Though job creation indicates economic activity, it is an incomplete measure of true economic health. Relying too heavily on this single factor overlooks key elements of long-term success:
Job Quality Matters More Than Quantity
In the manufacturing and food processing industries, job quality is a critical issue. Some companies in these sectors create entry-level positions that offer low wages and limited opportunities for advancement. For instance, the food processing industry, including major players like pet food producer Royal Canin USA, faces challenges with retaining employees because the wages often fall below the national average for manufacturing. While these businesses contribute to local employment figures, the quality of the jobs—characterized by low wages and high turnover—often leaves workers financially insecure, even if they are employed. This creates a mismatch between job quantity and true economic well-being
Temporary Jobs Can Inflate Employment Figures
Temporary jobs, especially those created during the construction of new manufacturing or processing facilities, can artificially inflate employment figures without providing long-term benefits. For example, Walmart’s investment in large-scale beef processing facilities in Nebraska and Kansas led to a surge in temporary construction jobs. However, once the facilities were built, the long-term employment opportunities did not match the short-term job growth, as many of the permanent positions were low-paying and offered limited upward mobility. This highlights how temporary jobs can boost employment numbers initially, but may not contribute meaningfully to long-term economic health.
Mismatch Between Jobs and Local Talent
Job creation efforts that don’t consider the skill levels of the local workforce can backfire. In Dayton, Ohio, the focus on attracting manufacturing jobs led to fewer long-term benefits because the workforce lacked the necessary skills for modern manufacturing positions. The gap between the jobs created and the available talent hindered the city’s economic progress.
Over-reliance on Incentives
A focus on job creation can sometimes lead communities to offer excessive incentives to lure companies. This approach often results in local governments sacrificing tax revenues for job promises that don’t materialize. For instance, Kansas City, Missouri, offered large tax incentives to attract businesses in the early 2000s, but many companies failed to deliver on their job creation promises, leaving the city with fewer benefits than anticipated.
Recently, Wisconsin has made significant changes to its business development tax credit program, shifting away from job creation as the primary metric for awarding incentives. The new guidelines emphasize factors such as capital investment and other economic benefits rather than solely focusing on the number of jobs created. This change reflects a broader understanding of economic development, recognizing that job quality and sustainability are more critical than simply increasing job counts.
Why a Broader Approach to Economic Development is Needed
Successful communities adopt a more holistic approach to economic development. Instead of focusing solely on job creation, they consider factors like business retention, workforce development, innovation, and quality of life improvements. By broadening the scope, they ensure a sustainable and prosperous future.
Case Study: Greenville, South Carolina
Greenville provides a compelling example of a city that transitioned from a job-creation-focused model to a comprehensive economic development strategy. In the 1970s, Greenville’s economy was centered around textiles and manufacturing. When these industries declined, the city needed a new plan. Rather than focusing solely on job numbers, Greenville invested in quality-of-life improvements and industries offering high-quality jobs, such as advanced manufacturing, healthcare, and technology.
Greenville’s strategy included:
Investing in Downtown Revitalization:
The city created a vibrant, walkable downtown with parks, arts venues, and local restaurants, making it attractive to both residents and businesses.
Fostering Innovation:
Greenville shifted its focus to industries offering high-wage jobs and opportunities for growth, such as tech and healthcare.
Public-Private Partnerships:
By collaborating with universities and businesses, Greenville ensured its workforce was prepared for the industries it sought to grow.
The result was a diversified economy that could better weather industry-specific downturns, population growth, and increased investment.
Broader Metrics for Economic Success
Communities that use multiple metrics to measure economic progress are better positioned for long-term prosperity. Here are some complementary metrics to job creation:
Workforce Development
Developing a skilled workforce that meets the needs of growing industries is crucial for economic success. Columbus, Ohio, has partnered with universities and businesses to offer training programs in sectors like logistics and technology, ensuring its workforce is ready for high-demand jobs.
Business Retention and Expansion
Supporting existing businesses is often more cost-effective than attracting new ones. Raleigh, North Carolina, excels at maintaining strong relationships with local businesses, helping them grow, and keeping the economy healthy.
Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Encouraging entrepreneurship can provide a more sustainable foundation than merely attracting outside companies. Austin, Texas, has fostered a startup-friendly environment that includes coworking spaces, venture capital, and networking opportunities, which has turned the city into a tech hub with a dynamic, resilient economy.
Quality of Life Improvements
Enhancing quality of life can attract both businesses and residents. Chattanooga, Tennessee, installed gigabit-speed internet citywide, making the area more appealing to tech companies and high-skill workers. This broadband initiative boosted competitiveness and spurred new sector growth.
The Role of Job Creation in a Broader Context
While job creation is an important part of economic development, it should be just one of many metrics used to assess success. Communities that focus too much on job numbers may miss out on the broader factors that drive sustainable economic growth.
By incorporating workforce development, business retention, innovation, and quality-of-life improvements into their strategies, communities can ensure they are building not just jobs, but a robust and resilient economy.
Conclusion: Moving Beyond Jobs
Job creation is an important tool, but it should not be the ultimate goal of economic development. Communities that broaden their approach—like Greenville, South Carolina—are better positioned for long-term prosperity. By balancing job creation with other key factors, they can foster sustainable growth that benefits everyone.
In the end, job creation should be viewed as one piece of the economic development puzzle, contributing to a much larger picture of community success.
Cited Content – Holzer, H. J. (2018). “The Quality of Jobs: What It Is and How to Measure It.”, Holtz-Eakin, D. (2014). “Temporary Jobs and Economic Recovery.” American Action Forum, Schwartz, J. (2021). “The Rise of Temporary Work: Is It Good for the Economy?” Harvard Business Review, Bessen, J. E. (2014). “How Technology Has Changed Careers.” Harvard Business Review, Autor, D. H., & Dorn, D. (2013). “The Growth of Low-Skill Service Jobs and the Polarization of the Labor Market.”, Florida, R. (2012). “The Rise of the Creative Class: Revisited.”, Evers, A., & Jonker, R. (2017). “The role of urban quality of life in economic growth.”, “Greenville’s Economic Transformation: A Case Study.” B. K. D. (2020). “Revitalizing Downtown: Lessons from Greenville, South Carolina.” Urban Land Institute, “Measuring Economic Success: Beyond Job Creation.” The National League of Cities.